A class apart documentary summary. A Class Apart (2009) 2022-11-15
A class apart documentary summary Rating:
9,9/10
1971
reviews
A Class Apart is a documentary film that tells the story of the 1954 landmark Supreme Court case Hernandez v. Texas. This case dealt with the issue of segregation and discrimination against Mexican Americans in Texas. It was the first time that the Supreme Court had ruled on a case involving Mexican Americans, and the decision had far-reaching implications for civil rights in the United States.
The film follows the story of Pete Hernandez, a Mexican American man who was charged with murder in a Texas court. Hernandez was denied a fair trial because the all-white jury was not representative of the community, and he was ultimately found guilty and sentenced to death.
Hernandez's case was taken up by the American G.I. Forum, a civil rights organization for Mexican Americans. The organization, along with Hernandez's lawyers, appealed the case to the Supreme Court, arguing that the segregation of Mexican Americans in Texas violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
The Supreme Court ultimately ruled in favor of Hernandez, stating that segregation on the basis of race or ethnicity was unconstitutional. This decision marked a significant victory for civil rights and paved the way for further progress in the fight against discrimination.
A Class Apart is a powerful and poignant reminder of the struggle for civil rights in the United States. It shows the resilience and determination of Mexican Americans who fought against discrimination and segregation, and the impact that their efforts had on the broader civil rights movement. The film is a testament to the power of the law to effect change and to the importance of standing up for one's rights. Overall, it is a compelling and important work that is well worth watching.
A Class Apart Film Analysis
. Martha Tevis: The men who were arguing the Hernandez case had to drive home to Houston every night from Edna, Texas. Narrator: GarcĂa had been an outstanding student at the University of Texas, captain of the nationally-ranked debate team; he had excelled at law school as well. The documentary illustrates the adversities the Mexican Americans had to face like segregation and being treated like second class citizens. The nine justices sitting on a long bench facing the two sets of parties. Prince, 2010 It is also though thiruling that the Civil rights of Mexican-Americans were recognized.
A Class Apart: A Mexican American Civil Rights Story
Narrator: At 36, Gus GarcĂa was already a local legend. Through the use of first person interviews and real footage, the piece gave me, what felt like, a clear look Social Stratification In The Movie The Help 610 Words 3 Pages Black women are treated less than because of their ascribed traits, their gender and race, and are often dehumanized and belittled throughout the movie. Texas belongs in the pantheon of great civil rights cases. When the results came in the justices ruled that the Texas courts were biased, the convicted murder was reversed and now needed a new trail among his own peers. They had no reason to believe that they would win. Apart from mythical narratives, we are all familiar with fragmentary utterances, apparently interrupted messages, suggestive juxtapositions Tyler Perry Analysis 1. Elliot reuniting with the students who she did this experiment with the first time.
Victor RodrĂguez: He came back, entered the cantina, and shot Joe Espinosa, in the heart. We were considered second rate, we were not considered intelligent. Narrator: Then came World War Two. Finally, they had the case they wanted before the United States Supreme Court. It took that jury less than four hours to reach its verdict. So he stole sixteen extra minutes.
I think Mexican Americans in particular, Latinos in general but America as a whole owes a great debt to the people who pursued this case. These are the three most common Hispanic origins and the rest of the Latino population identifies with other Hispanic nationalities. Essay About Being Mexican Americans 757 Words 4 Pages Hispanic Americans, or Latinos, are a very large and diverse ethnic group in the U. The experiment was done days after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. Garcia, however he eventually became Chief Justice, which was a great accomplishment. These protests by students were one of the first major protests by Mexican Americans against racism and helped greatly to ignite the Chicano Movement. .
Elliott implement her exercise regarding discrimination and racism. For example, a woman in the documentary described when she was teased by neighborhood kids for being Mexican and when she retaliated, the father of the bully treated to hit her. There was widespread exclusion of people of Mexican origin from all types of judicial work in the whole of Texas. Lignin is the glue that holds fibers together. Instead, the returning veterans, many of them decorated war heroes, came back to face the same injustices they had experienced all their lives. Look at what â how we presented our case to the nation. Herrera Audio: Gus GarcĂa was told to proceed.
Texas story and I first learnt about it from a history class as well later in the series itself when it was released in 2009 A Class ApartâŚ. He was able to unite the poor people and spark the revolution against the Spanish and against the upper class. He gets on the radio and he starts pleading for donations. It was not until 1970 when the Supreme Court in Cisneros vs. Eleanor McCusker: He was tall and he was slender, he had coal black hair and those green penetrating eyes that ah in my view made him very handsome. Many funeral parlors even refused to prepare Mexican American bodies for burial.
. From this time onward, they were treated as second class citizens that were not able to acquire the rights that they deserved. . From this seemingly unremarkable small-town murder emerged a landmark civil rights case that would forever change the lives and legal standing of tens of millions of Americans. .
One time I said something really nasty to one of them and the father of this kid came up and asked me to step off the sidewalk so he could hit me. The drawback from this is that Mr. Look at how we have finally made the people of the United States listen. Cadena won a ruling that ended restrictive covenants barring Mexican Americans from buying homes in Anglo neighborhoods. And that county as it turned out there had never been a Hispanic in modern times ever served on either a grand jury, petit jury, or any other type of jury.
In the film it showed Mexican Americans, frustration by the President discrimination and poverty. Eleanor McCusker: Carlos was the quiet one, always doing the heavy research. The Hernandez petition arrived on January 21st, a day late, typewritten. As legal skirmishes unfolded, the lawyers emerged as brilliant, dedicated, humorous, and at times, terribly flawed men. Despite the assimilation by the majority whites the Chicanos have preserved their culture. The rate of Latino that graduate from a 4-year universities is very low, because if the equal opportunities of scholarships among them.
