Disadvantages of rigid constitution. What are the advantages and disadvantages of a constitution? 2022-11-17
Disadvantages of rigid constitution Rating:
A rigid constitution is a type of constitutional framework that is difficult to amend or change. This means that any changes or modifications to the constitution must go through a strict and rigorous process, which can be lengthy and time-consuming. While there are some advantages to having a rigid constitution, such as providing stability and protecting fundamental rights, there are also several disadvantages that should be considered.
One of the main disadvantages of a rigid constitution is that it can hinder the ability of the government to respond to changing circumstances and needs. In a rapidly changing world, it is important for a government to have the flexibility to adapt to new challenges and opportunities. With a rigid constitution, it can be difficult to make necessary changes to laws and policies, even if they are urgently needed. This can lead to a government that is unable to effectively address the needs of its citizens and may result in stagnation or inefficiency.
Another disadvantage of a rigid constitution is that it can create a sense of detachment between the government and the people. A constitution that is difficult to change may not accurately reflect the values and concerns of the current population. This can lead to a feeling of disconnection and frustration among the public, who may feel that their voices are not being heard or that their needs are not being addressed. This can erode trust and confidence in the government, leading to a decrease in support and legitimacy.
In addition, a rigid constitution can also limit the ability of the government to address social and economic issues. It can be difficult to enact necessary reforms or make changes to policies that address pressing issues such as inequality, poverty, or environmental concerns. This can result in a government that is unable to address the needs of its citizens and may be seen as out of touch or ineffective.
Finally, a rigid constitution can also contribute to political polarization and conflict. In a system where it is difficult to make changes, there may be a tendency for different groups to fight over the limited opportunities to shape policy or laws. This can lead to increased tension and disagreement, as different groups try to push their agendas through the narrow channels available.
In conclusion, while a rigid constitution can provide stability and protect fundamental rights, it also has several disadvantages. It can hinder the ability of the government to respond to changing circumstances and needs, create a sense of detachment between the government and the people, limit the ability to address social and economic issues, and contribute to political polarization and conflict. It is important to carefully consider these disadvantages when evaluating the pros and cons of a rigid constitution.
Rigid Constitution: Definition, Advantages And Disadvantages
The first draft that was produced by the drafting committee was in the year 1948, in the month of February, the first draft was thrown open to debate and then the second draft was produced. Written constitution are mostly rigid, with cumbersome amendment procedure, which leads to the problem of how to easily amend it to make it suit changing needs and time. This continued until when I was about to represent my school in a political science competition. Legitimacy: When there is an established and consistent procedure for law making, which is tenaciously followed, it lends weight and legality to the laws made and compels more obedience from the people. Rigidity of constitution places a constraint on the legal development of a political entity.
What are the merits and demerits of Rigid constitution?
Advantages and disadvantages of a written constitution:Written constitution is one of the types of constitution that has been adopted in most countries of the world. This may lead to a revolution by people or coup by military. Thus, the central government will not be faced with too many works. This exposes the constitution to judicial intervention. Nonetheless, I will still give you a comprehensive explanation of the differences between flexible and rigid constitution as we continue. This is why there is still arguments amongst as to whether a written constitution is the best type of constitution or not.
Differences Between Rigid And Flexible Constitution
. It is impossible to foresee all developments and conditions which may arise in future at the time of framing the constitution. The drafting process was done during the recess which is from the month of July in the year 1947 to September 1948; the recess time was the time when the constituent assembly was not taking place. On the other hand, a flexible government is more suitable for a unitary system of government with a homogeneous population. Some scope for growth must, therefore, be kept by introducing an element of flexibility in the constitution.
A rigid constitution constitution where every arm of government is functioning maximally with checks and balances and not at the pleasure of executive, does not encourage the emergence of a dictator, because an individual, or cabal with dictatorial propensity cannot easily hoodwinked the legislature which represents the people. This definition also state that the rules are codified in a document known as the constitution. Explain the rigid features of a constitution. Rigidity lends legitimacy to the constitution. The residual list includes chieftaincy affairs, motor parks and market stalls, local taxes collections, while the concurrent list contains issues such as education, agriculture, health services, road construction, etc.
Advantages and Disadvantages of a Written Constitution
In Over 200 years, the constitution of the United States has been amended only 27 times. The government cannot change the basic structure of the constitution if it wants to. Although, other laws may be incorporated into it by reference in its provisions. . In a country like Nigeria, for instance, for a modification to the constitution to be effected, it must be passed by a four-fifth majority of all the members of both the Senate and the House of Representatives, i.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a constitution?
RECOMMENDED: Advantages of a Rigid Constitution Demerits The following are the arguments in favour of the rigid constitution: 1. Coupled with this, citizens can also sue the government to ensure that it performs its governmental duties. One of the topics I loved so much during my secondary school days is the Types of constitution. Protection of the minority: A rigid constitution protects minority peoples and other disadvantaged groups. Those are the features or characteristics of a written constitution. He was a well-known member of the assembly.
Advantages and disadvantages of Rigid constitution.
It helps to ensure that amendment that is made to the constitution will be duly deliberated before it is made. It was written by the British who did not allow Nigerians to make any suggestions for the contents of the constitution. However, the fact that is can not be easily amended even in time of emergency is a disadvantage. I enjoin you to read this topic carefully if you really want to grasp the information contained in it. It is easy for citizens to know when their rights have been breached, when the acts of government or public officials are unconstitutional, so that they can sue based on the provisions of the constitution.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Federal System of Government
Hence the rigid constitution is stable in nature. With what I have discussed so far, I am sure you have been able to pick points some of the differences between a rigid and flexible construction already. Ambedkar was the chairman of a committee in the Indian constituent assembly called as drafting committee. For the first time, Nigerians took part in the discussions that finally led to the writing of a new constitution in 1951. He was a well-known member of the assembly. Thanks for stopping by.