A nursing research critique paper is a detailed analysis and evaluation of a research study, specifically one related to nursing. It is important for nurses to critique research studies in order to determine the validity and reliability of the findings, as well as to identify any potential biases or limitations. By critically examining research papers, nurses can apply the knowledge gained from the study to their practice and make informed decisions about patient care.
One example of a nursing research critique paper is a study on the effectiveness of using virtual reality as a pain management tool for hospitalized children. This study was conducted by researchers at the University of Alabama at Birmingham and published in the Journal of Pediatric Nursing.
In the study, the researchers recruited a sample of hospitalized children between the ages of 8 and 12 who were experiencing moderate to severe pain. The children were randomly assigned to either a control group or an experimental group. The experimental group received virtual reality therapy in addition to their usual pain management techniques, while the control group received only their usual pain management techniques.
The researchers found that the children in the experimental group experienced a significant reduction in pain compared to the control group. They also reported improvements in their mood and a decrease in the use of pain medication.
One strength of this study is that it used a randomized controlled design, which helps to control for extraneous variables and reduces the risk of bias. Additionally, the researchers used multiple measures to assess pain, including self-report measures and physiological measures, which helps to increase the validity of the findings.
However, there are also some limitations to this study. For example, the sample size was relatively small, with only 40 children participating in the study. This could potentially limit the generalizability of the findings to other populations. Additionally, the study only looked at the short-term effects of virtual reality therapy, so it is unclear if the benefits would be sustained over a longer period of time.
Overall, this nursing research critique paper demonstrates the potential benefits of using virtual reality as a pain management tool for hospitalized children. While there are some limitations to the study, the findings suggest that virtual reality therapy may be a useful addition to the pain management strategies for this population.
Critique Of A Research Article Nursing Essay
The findings were interesting, although it might become more reliable if the study was replicated using a larger, random sample group. Data Management and Analysis Levels of satisfaction of the nurses who had primary nursing positions and nursing careers were measured to allow for a possible cross tabulation during activities of reporting. The general recommendation is that sample sizes be at least 30 and need not be larger than 500 at 500, sample error will not exceed 10 percent of the standard deviation about 98 percent of the time. According to Polit and Beck 2004 the aim of critically appraising an article is an attempt to determine its strengths and limitations. There should be clear hyperlinks between the aims of the research research and the literature evaluation, the choice of research designs and means used to gather information, the discussion of the problems, and its conclusions and suggestions Nordquist, 2009. Consequently, in a bid to weigh in to the debate, Cork 2014 conducted a study investigating the extent and efficacy of intuition-based decisions by the charge nurses in trauma cases.
Critiquing A Research Article Qualitative Nursing Essay
The authors discuss several limitations of the study, including the small sample size, the use of a single Health Literacy Scale, and the fact that the study was conducted in a single hospital. Research Question Although the research question has not been explicitly stated in the article, it is implied. A literature review is a means of reading, analyzing, evaluating, and summarizing scholarly materials a couple of specific subject Sage, 1998. The author clearly stated the gaps in the knowledge, in previous study it was identified that to provide good quality of care and to understand interpersonal aspect of care is essential and residents are primary source to find out the interpersonal factor and outcomes of care, on other hand recent study provide better understanding of interpersonal factor by taking depth interviews of the residence in order to improve the residents relationship with their nurses and also in the improvement of the quality of nursing. Did the analysis yield an insightful, provocative, and meaningful picture of the phenomenon under investigation? They discuss the demographic information of the participants, the Health Literacy Scale scores for both groups of patients, and the differences between the two groups. The hospital records evaluated the professional performance of the trauma nurses in making accurate assessments of their patients stabilization needs before transferring them to a higher-level trauma center. The author did not make any conceptual framework for this study, he just compare and contrast the content on one research theory to compare the content of the study.
Critique Nursing
An electronic tool was used for mind mapping as well. Russell 2004 also states that the introduction should thoroughly describe the background of the research problem so that the need for the study is apparent. General Impression Overall the article was interesting with clear aims and use of methodology. Inferential statistics, which are based on the laws of probability, provide a means for drawing conclusions about a population, given data from a sample. If a conceptual framework or ideological orientation guided the study, are the themes or patterns linked to it in a cogent manner? If not, is their absence justified? It is not until the Findings section that the size of the sample is revealed - 169 participants responded. It was difficult to identify the exact research question, as there was no definite question asked. For instance, in case a respondent lied or gave inaccurate responses there was no way for the researcher to know.
Nursing Research Article Critique Paper Example
Also, its absence was not justified. Also, more support from managers was noted to be the top ranked facilitator of research implementation. Does the problem have significance for nursing? Descriptive method is used to explain the current behavior or characteristics of a particular population. This study provide some evidence that can be used in nursing practice in help in improving Beck, 2009. Through this Nursing critique paper example assignment, the student will: Critique a peer-reviewed study, and in your own words, describe the research question, sample, design of study, data collection method, findings, and limitations of each.
