If we must die. If We Must Die: A Novel of Tulsa's 1921 Greenwood Riot by Pat Carr 2022-10-27

If we must die Rating: 4,8/10 1689 reviews

If We Must Die is a poem written by Claude McKay in 1919, during a time of great racial tension and violence in the United States. The poem speaks to the experience of African Americans facing oppression and discrimination, and encourages them to stand up for their rights and to fight back against their oppressors.

The poem begins with the line "If we must die, let it not be like hogs" which immediately sets the tone of defiance and resistance. The reference to hogs suggests that the speaker believes that African Americans are being treated as nothing more than animals, and that they deserve a better fate. This line also hints at the violence and brutality that African Americans were often subjected to, as hogs were often slaughtered in a similar manner.

The speaker goes on to say that they would rather "dwell in the fields" and "slumber by the prostrate grain" than submit to their oppressors. The use of the word "prostrate" here is significant, as it suggests that the speaker sees themselves as being in a subservient position, but that they are not willing to stay there. Instead, they would rather die on their own terms, in a place where they are free to live their lives as they please.

The speaker then addresses their oppressors, saying "we are the young men who die for a dream". This line highlights the fact that the speaker and their fellow African Americans are fighting for something greater than themselves - they are fighting for a better future and for their dreams to be realized. The use of the word "young" also suggests that the speaker and their peers are not willing to wait for change to come, but are instead taking action to bring about the changes they desire.

In the final lines of the poem, the speaker declares that they will not go quietly into the night, but will instead "face the murderous, cowardly pack" and "pelt them with the courage of despair". The use of the word "murderous" suggests that the speaker sees their oppressors as being ruthless and willing to use violence against them, while the word "cowardly" implies that the speaker believes their oppressors are afraid of what they stand for. The final line, "pelt them with the courage of despair", speaks to the idea that the speaker and their peers will not let their situation defeat them, but will instead fight back with all the strength they have, even in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds.

Overall, If We Must Die is a powerful and inspiring poem that speaks to the resilience and determination of African Americans in the face of adversity. It encourages readers to stand up for what they believe in and to fight for their rights, no matter the cost.

If We Must Die: Poem, Summary & Analysis

if we must die

How long, how long will you mock us with your words? He believes that even though most people aren't able to fight or show courage, some do so just by being willing to put themselves at risk. I would recommend reading both of t I have had this book for awhile, but I finally had time to read it. It is a book that makes readers want to know more. The citation above will include either 2 or 3 dates. They had to hand their mobile phones in before they head out to his mansion. If death is to be the fate of Black Americans, McKay continues, then their deaths should be noble and dignified.

Next

If We Must Die Analysis

if we must die

The case of a missing manuscript takes a dramatic turn when Frank and Lu find themselves trapped in famous author Greg Alban's house, where no-one is who they seem. These include alliteration, enjambment, metaphor, and repetition. Her lips tasted as sweet as sugar. However, I do not see me sharing this book with him or anyone else for that matter. If we must die , O let us nobly die , So that our precious blood may not be shed In vain ; then even the monsters we defy Shall be constrained to honor us though dead! The rebellious, call-to-action feel of the poem is accomplished by a variety of different poetic techniques. It also creates an adversarial dynamic that further supports the poem's thesis. In If We Must Die novelist Pat Carr turns that tragedy into a riveting novel.

Next

If We Must Die Poem Summary and Analysis

if we must die

My 8th graders will love reading this book but learn so much from its content. It is important that they fight back against what is clearly a metaphor for oppression. This is open to interpretation and analysis. For there is no hope for our kind if we do not fight free from fear. By using imagery, writers can evoke the feeling they want to talk about in their readers…and by making their readers feel, writers can also help readers connect to the messages in their work. The story of their desperate attempt to escape is realistic and frightening, made more so by its historical accuracy. As the main character realizes more and more about her own white privelege, readers are forced to take a clear eyed view of our current society.

Next

If We Must Die

if we must die

Though far outnumbered let us show us brave, And for their thousand blows deal one death-blow! The answer here is simple: fight back against the enemy. Like men we'll face the murderous, cowardly pack , Pressed to the wall, dying, but fighting back! The author tells a lot with a little. What are the poetic devices in if we must die? Finally, McKay wants readers to understand that even though there are wars between countries, there are also smaller conflicts within each country. If we must die, O let us nobly die, So that our precious blood may not be shed In vain; then even the monsters we defy Shall be constrained to honor us though dead! Here is the entire poem: If we must die, let us hope that we may live long enough to kill our enemies! The heroine is not who I expected when I opened the book. So let us fight like men who know they are going to die! See eNotes Ad-Free Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. Though far outnumbered let us show us brave And for their thousand blows deal one deathblow! The re-life events are ugly enough as they are, but still worth reading multiple accounts to educate yourself on your own if that's how you have to do that.

Next

A Summary and Analysis of Claude McKay’s ‘If We Must Die’

if we must die

How do you identify imagery? It isn't in the textbooks, but it is a story that must be told. . I would recommend reading both of them, then doing more research. When Berneen O'Brien's mother dies, the seventeen-year-old moves from Wyoming to Tulsa to live with her stern uncle. I would love to see this book read by every person who thinks that racism is an issue of the past.

Next

What is the meaning of If We Must Die?

if we must die

Who is the audience for us if we must die? In If We Must Die novelist Pat Carr turns that tragedy into a riveting novel. Quite interesting and very eye-opening. The second is the date of publication online or last modification online. . This was not a riot. The book is excellent and the author's use of the main character's passing as white it frightening.

Next

If We Must Die: A Novel of Tulsa's 1921 Greenwood Riot by Pat Carr

if we must die

The teacher is fictional but the story is all too real. He hopes, that this will lead them to a victory as well. How do you describe imagery? There were moments when I found myself shocked and hesitant to precede because of Ms. It was written in 1919, a time of deep racial tension in America. This re-telling, realistic fiction novel does a great job explaining the point of view of Berneen O'Brien and her new work experinces in a black elementry school. This novel is both insightful and a real page-turner.


Next

If We Must Die by Claude McKay

if we must die

Although Black Americans are the minority, they can at least meet their enemy in a brave and courageous manner. Do you not know how idiotic you look? Her worries about being an outcast soon disappear, as the other teachers make her welcome. Here are just a few: Battle of Hastings - 1066 Battle of Trafalgar - 1805 First Battle of Ypres - 1914 Battle of France - 1940 Battle of Britain - 1940 D-Day - 1944 Vietnam War - 1959 1970 Gulf War - 1990 War on Terror - 2001 Occupied Japan - 1945 Korean War - 1950 1953 What is the rhyme scheme of if we must die? An easy way to spot imagery in a text is to pay attention to words, phrases, and sentences that connect with your five senses sight, smell, taste, touch, and sound. But several new studies have focused attention on Tulsa's Greenwood race riot of 1921. No matter how bad your situation seems to be, it can always be improved if you only try hard enough. Select any word below to get its definition in the context of the poem. This has been a story long-hidden or long-ignored in history books or classes that we all knew about when we were younger.

Next

What Does the Poem "If We Must Die" by Claude McKay Mean?

if we must die

By evoking those senses through touch, taste, sound, smell, and sight, the writer imparts a deeper understanding of the human experience, connecting with the reader through a shared sensory experience. And she finds herself increasingly drawn to Nelson Flowers. This brings the a and b rhymes in closer and creates a claustrophobic effect. Finally, he asserts that even though we may face death, it cannot conquer spirit. Whites burn Greenwood and storm the neighborhood, shooting and beating black men, women, and children. Carr leaves us with one revelation that sticks with me.

Next

Claude McKay

if we must die

It is a poem of political resistance: it calls for oppressed people to resist their oppressors, violently and bravely—even if they die in the struggle. . Additionally, the Shakespearean sonnet is an art form that is often lauded by white academics and is typically studied alongside an overwhelming white Western canon. His words felt like a dagger in my heart. How can you create historical fiction, for children, around one of the most horrific; yet often erased, events in modern American history? Her worries about being an outcast soon disappear, as the other teachers make her welcome.

Next