John q analysis. John Q 2022-10-27
John q analysis
Rating:
9,3/10
950
reviews
"John Q" is a dramatic film released in 2002 that tells the story of a working-class father named John Quincy Archibald (played by Denzel Washington) who fights to save the life of his critically ill son, Michael (played by Daniel E. Smith). The film raises important issues about the state of healthcare in the United States and the difficulties that many people face in accessing medical treatment.
At the beginning of the film, John and his wife Denise (played by Kimberly Elise) learn that their son Michael has a severe heart condition that requires a heart transplant. However, they are unable to afford the high cost of the procedure, which is not covered by their health insurance. Desperate to save his son's life, John takes matters into his own hands and takes hostages at the hospital where Michael is being treated, demanding that his son be given the transplant.
Throughout the film, John is portrayed as a loving and determined father who is willing to do whatever it takes to save his son's life. Despite the initial hostility of the hostages and the hospital staff, John eventually wins their respect and support as they come to understand the depth of his love for his son and the struggles he has faced in trying to get medical treatment.
One of the central themes of "John Q" is the role of healthcare in society and the ways in which it is affected by economic and political factors. The film highlights the fact that many people in the United States do not have access to affordable healthcare, and that those who do are often forced to choose between their financial well-being and their health. This theme is brought to the forefront when John and Denise are told that their insurance will not cover Michael's transplant and that they must come up with $250,000 in order to pay for the procedure.
Another important theme in "John Q" is the power of individual action and the ability of one person to make a difference. John's actions may seem extreme, but they ultimately lead to a positive outcome for his son and bring attention to the issue of healthcare access. The film suggests that by standing up for what we believe in and taking bold action, we can effect change and bring about positive change in society.
Overall, "John Q" is a thought-provoking and emotionally powerful film that raises important issues about healthcare and the struggles that many people face in accessing medical treatment. It is a poignant reminder of the importance of standing up for what we believe in and the power of individual action to bring about change.
John Q Ethical Dilemma Analysis
This circumstance is well presented in the movie John Q, written by James Kearns. As they are climbing the mountain they run into a nearly naked Indian holy man that is near death. Even when John took hostages, he was kind to them. John is very loyal to his peers and stands up for what he knows is John Q Essay 515 Words 3 Pages In the movie "John Q"—alluding to John Q Public, the average guy—Denzel Washington—plays a working-class African American man in Chicago whose manufacturing job has been cut back to 20 hours a week. An example of this is when the hospital decides to discharge the child even though his father paid six thousand dollars the day before. It appeared that men based their judgement more on abstract ideas while women on care and concern for relationships Martin et al.
Next
Dramatic Analysis Of The Film John Q: [Essay Example], 1210 words GradesFixer
Once at the hospital they find their nine-year-old son Michael is diagnosed with an enlarged heart and needs a heart transplant as soon as possible, or he will not survive much longer. The doctors don't send them so the Insurance doesn't have to cover. John should have handled the situation much differently than keeping innocent people hostage. John Q had worked in the. She faced a hard decision and ended up regretting denying Michael in the first place. This movie stars Denzel Washington, Robert Duvall, James Wood, and Ray Liotta. No matter if the movie belongs to a big banner or a small banner, whether it is a thumbs up or a super flop, companies have vigorously used this technique, to advertise their brands and thus increase their visibility.
Next
John Q Analysis
Fueling the debate over effective care allocation strategies, for decades the media has been filled with the echoes of socialized healthcare, and in recent decades multiple nations have adopted the model of a governmentalized healthcare system. One day after church they rush their young son Michael to the hospital after he collapses at his baseball game, and are told by cardiologist Dr. What is the connection between law and morality? The boy suffers from an enlarged heart that went undetected so far. Archibald deceived and manipulated hostages and hospital administrators as a means to his desired end, is in conflict with the familiar categorical imperative of Kantian Deontology. Though many people have health insurance, many are health care illiterate. Desperate to keep their son alive, John Q and Denise scramble to get the cash they need to keep their son in the hospital.
Next
John Q
. John Q has fallen on hard times, but he 's dedicated to his family and the American dream—and still manages to carry limited medical insurance. As he holds the gun to his own head a second time and prepares to end his life, his wife is told about a woman killed in a car crash, the one from the opening scene, who happens to have the same blood type as Michael, and has been flown to the hospital for organ recovery. By my rationale, if one is able to pay for, or has coverage that can pay for a procedure the individual is probably more able to make contributions to the market and thus society as a consumer, and might also have a higher probability of possessing the intellectual capacity and education level that is thought to enable one in providing the most useful contributions to society. The question is, could all of these dilemmas occur to a white male main character? He is found guilty of kidnapping, and thus has to suffer for his actions in jail. Being human all he was self absorbed in was the fact that he wanted to have this problem Just go away so he didn't look bad.
Next
John Q: an Ethical Analys and Review Analysis Essay Example
The effects of organ procurement can instill a sense of helplessness in those linked to the patient dying from a terminal condition. John Q: an Ethical Analys and Review Essay Washington is shown using a grinder as he stands over a tubesheet destined for a steam generator for a nuclear power generating facility. Rights Approach: This principle states that an action is ethical if it protects or advances moral rights. Franks persuasion worked when john agreed to let some of the hostages go on condition that frank had an hour to get Mike on the list before john started killing hostages. To that end, there would have been no reason for John Q.
Next
The Movie John Q: Ethical Dilemmas: [Essay Example], 1445 words GradesFixer
Frank Grimes makes contact with John, who demands Payne put Michael's name on the organ transplant list. On the contrary, it was due to the way the directors, and the staff of the hospital were handling the problem. An excellent example of this is when we acknowledge that Mr. Turner, in the Emergency Department. Even if an African-American was one of the greatest surgeons around, that person probably wouldn't be given a job. Despite her bitterness in the beginning she changed her outlook after hearing John converse with his son.
Next
John Q
In the end John hangs for his sin but keeps his integrity. The scene is kind or ironic because people go to a hospital to get treated and feel better, but here they are being held hostage at this very sanctuary. Distributive justice, Ethics, Health care 3010 Words 8 Pages John Q. His son remains in the hospital, progressively get worse due to his heart condition, while John tries to get the money to get his son on the transplant list. Kohlberg had been criticised for ignoring other factors which are related to moral functioning such as emotion Gibbs, 1991.
Next
Reviewing The Behavioral And Moral Lessons From John Q, A Film By Nick Cassavetes: [Essay Example], 1079 words GradesFixer
Archibald would probably not have been avoided. John and Denise do everything they can think from selling their truck to, getting help from the church, and borrowing money from friends. He is out of control, but has a view of the overall picture. The agent is the person performing the unlawful behaviour, and this is without a doubt John Archibald. To the same effect, the usefulness of the mentally ill or elderly can be perceived to be lessened because they have less years or intellectual contributions to make to society.
Next
Ethical Concerns for John Q Analysis Essay Example
The New Line Cinema Presentation of John Q. Not only were the hostages and huge crowd gathered around the hospital hoping John got what he wanted, myself as the viewer was really hoping he got his son the transplant. John actions were not handled properly; he was not an ethical person at all by performing the actions he did. John Q 2002 At the heart of social usefulness allocation is the idea of instrumental value, that is, that which shows promise of future usefulness Emanuel et al. It is unclear whether the director chose for John Q. John and his wife were at a ballgame watching their son play baseball when their son collapses on the field. The picture illustrates the manifestation of this stress and emotional strain in irrational behavior of the father of a terminal child and seems to justify his actions by hinting at the unjust nature of the organ distributive process.
Next
John Q.
Once the heart arrives, John releases the hostages, including patient Lester, who surrenders to police posing as John. Moreover, a brief update on the events depicted in the film will be provided, which will mainly consist of the consequences and principle characters John Q and the hospital ultimately suffered as a turn-out of the events within the movie, as well as the benefits they gained. In fact, even his hostages after being released; tell news reporters that John is a great man, a hero of sorts. The unbelievable decision of John Q in killing himself to donate his heart to his son also ethically impacted the life of the cardiac surgeon. The Problems Associated with Low Health Literacy. Once the reader gets to know St. He should have gone to the mayor, government, and congressman.
Next