Pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents. Guest column/The top 3 pros and cons of corporal punishment 2022-11-17

Pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents Rating: 7,1/10 1595 reviews

Corporal punishment by parents, also known as physical discipline or spanking, is a controversial topic. It involves the use of physical force, such as hitting or spanking, as a form of punishment for children’s misbehavior. While some people argue that corporal punishment is an effective way to discipline children and teach them right from wrong, others believe it is harmful and can have negative effects on children’s development. In this essay, we will explore the pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents.

One argument in favor of corporal punishment is that it is a quick and effective way to discipline children. When a child misbehaves, a swift and firm punishment can be effective in getting the child to immediately stop their misbehavior and understand that it is wrong. Some people argue that corporal punishment is a necessary and effective tool for teaching children self-control, respect, and obedience.

However, there are also several arguments against corporal punishment. One concern is that it can be harmful to children’s physical and mental health. Physical punishment can cause physical pain and injury to children, and it can also lead to feelings of fear, anxiety, and low self-esteem. Research has shown that children who are subjected to corporal punishment are more likely to experience depression, aggression, and behavior problems in the future. In addition, corporal punishment can teach children to be afraid of their parents, rather than teaching them to understand and correct their misbehavior.

Another argument against corporal punishment is that it is not an effective long-term solution for disciplining children. While it may be effective in the moment, it does not teach children how to behave appropriately in the future. Instead, it relies on fear and punishment to control children’s behavior, rather than helping them to understand and internalize appropriate behavior.

There are also cultural and legal considerations to take into account when discussing the use of corporal punishment by parents. In many countries, corporal punishment by parents is illegal, while in others it is accepted and even encouraged. In some cultures, corporal punishment is seen as a normal and necessary part of parenting, while in others it is viewed as a form of child abuse.

In conclusion, the use of corporal punishment by parents is a complex and controversial issue. While it may be effective in the moment, it can have negative effects on children’s physical and mental health and is not an effective long-term solution for disciplining children. There are also cultural and legal considerations to take into account. Ultimately, the decision to use corporal punishment should be made carefully, taking into account the individual needs and circumstances of the child and family.

Argumentative Essay: Should We Use Corporal Punishment?

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Whether it is right or wrong remains to be a contentious topic. Thus, they refrain from committing such infractions and the inappropriate behavior is extinguished. Another reason why corporal punishment is wrong is that it can have serious physical and emotional consequences for children. This can cause legal issues and lead to unwanted attention from child protection agencies. It is important for parents and caregivers to understand and use these approaches to help children grow and develop in a healthy and positive way. It is defined as a physical punishment which involves hitting someone.

Next

6 Pros and Cons of Corporal Punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

The risks of resorting to this consequence in a moment of anger are what limit its overall effectiveness. Although there are advantages in the creation of a shock factor when trying to teach a child a lesson, there is a difference between teaching through fear and teaching through love and concern. The Benefits Of Corporal Punishment Corporal punishment in school refers to disciplinary action that is physical in nature and delivered by teachers or school administrators as punishment for some type of student misbehavior. When it comes to disciplining children, parents can have opposing views on how to rear their kids. Corporal punishment is discipline intended to cause pain, commonly towards a child. The way in which religious customs turn into pointless ideologies or means to obtain the upper hand is frightening. As Daryl Scoggin, the superintendent of the school district and Tate County, Mississippi, told EdWeek.

Next

The Pros And Cons Of Physical Punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Why corporal punishment does not work? Though some may claim there is a line between abuse and corporal punishment, they are effectively the same. Corporal punishment may negatively affect both the parent and the child, leaving them with heavy hearts and troubled minds. Imagine not having a safe place to go to. In fact, just the opposite has transpired due to the boundaries that are set regarding unbecoming behavior. Physical punishment can result in bruises, cuts, and other injuries, and can also lead to more serious long-term physical health problems. A child who went through so much painful punishment may have a tendency to become violent to their peers and other people.

Next

18 Corporal Punishment Pros and Cons

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

The most effective use of corporal punishment involves children who are in the preschool age range which have committed willful disobedience. List of Pros of Corporal Punishment 1. And so there are more - there are higher numbers of white students getting paddled than, you know, black students, for example. First top pro: Corporal punishment is the appropriate discipline for certain children when used in moderation. Do the parents need to be notified afterwards? Another strategy is called logical consequences e.

Next

Guest column/The top 3 pros and cons of corporal punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Setting clear expectations and consequences for misbehavior, and consistently enforcing those consequences, can also be effective in promoting good behavior. Spanking Argumentative Essay 573 Words 3 Pages Would you say that spanking is appropriate? It sets clear boundaries that motivate children to behave at home or in school. There are 54 countries which banned corporal punishment in every circumstance, including as a consequence option for parents at home. Punishment may take the form of suspension, corporal punishment, manual work, expulsion, dismissal, isolation, detention after school, scolding, written lines, restitution, being sent to the headmaster and being deprived of certain privileges ibid. When it's The Pros And Cons Of Corporal Punishment Corporal punishment in the home is a very controversial topic. Those that are left are firmly entrenched in the idea that it is safe and effective.

Next

The Pros and Cons of Corporal Punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

However punishment is to correct a behavior it is not meant to be solely convenient. Given the ability shared by both men, it seemed too coincidental that they would each pass away within one day of each other: Black Stalin on December 28, and Pelé the following day. The schools in states were corporal punishment is permitted perform worse on the national academic assessment each year compared to the states that prohibit corporal punishment. The child immediately stops misbehaving, accepts the punishment, and does a short-term compliance. Rodriguez advises parents to think strategically and plan ahead. There is the potential that someone could administer it incorrectly.

Next

Positive Effects of Being Spanked As a Child

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Source 8 It Can Lead To Mental Illnesses: The fear, anger and resentment caused by corporal punishment can lead to mental illnesses. These are the children who typically respond in severe circumstances to a physical consequence that is appropriate for the behaviors they have chosen. Corporal punishment, in whatever form it is applied, creates a shocking circumstance for the child which helps them to remember that their choices could create harm in some way. The definition of corporal punishment is, a physical punishment , as flogging, inflicted on the body of one convicted of a crime Dictionary. For example, African Americans and people who translate the bible literally are more likely to use spanking as a means of punishment 206. In time, hopefully the negative reinforcement will stop the bad behavior.

Next

Pros And Cons Of Corporal Punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Those nations are Guiana, Botswana, Malaysia, Nigeria, Palestine, Somalia, Saudi Arabia, Mauritania, and Tanzania. Those who use corporal punishment or even spanking gives them control over those under disciplinary action. Conversely, the parent who hits his or her kid might not also like the act but since this is something that he or she has been brought up with, the act still has to push through and as a result, makes the parent think he or she is a failure as a parent. Corporal punishment should be allowed because it is a lasting punishment, is able to to Pros And Cons Of The Corporal Punishment Of Children? It tends to be a choice that students prefer. It establishes a boundary between who is in charge, and what the rules happen to be.

Next

Pros and cons of corporal punishment

pros and cons of corporal punishment by parents

Source 9 It Can Cause Children To Lie: Children are likely to lie if they know corporal punishment is a possibility. Critics call it child abuse and note that students continue to misbehave even after repeated spankings. Presently, 19 states still allow corporal punishment. I just disagree there is never a place for spanking. Furthermore, as previously mentioned, corporal punishment solved my discipline problems in the classroom as a first-year teacher in the Pittsburgh Public Schools System. In conclusion, adults ought to consider the effects of corporal punishment before they employ its Knowledge Spanking Tradition 2009 Words 9 Pages While it is becoming common knowledge spanking has negative impacts on the emotional and psychological health of children, the practice still endures in American society. It can cause harm to children and adolescents and disproportionately affects marginalized groups.

Next