Pros and cons of sparta. Athens vs Sparta 2022-11-15
Pros and cons of sparta Rating:
8,8/10
370
reviews
Sparta was a city-state in ancient Greece that is known for its strict social and political system, as well as its formidable military. While the Sparta system had some advantages, it also had several drawbacks that had significant impacts on its citizens and on the broader ancient Greek world.
One of the main advantages of the Sparta system was its military strength. The Sparta system placed a strong emphasis on military training and discipline, and as a result, the city-state was able to field one of the most formidable armies in the ancient Greek world. This military strength allowed Sparta to expand its territory and influence, and also served as a deterrent against other city-states or foreign powers that might have considered attacking Sparta.
Another advantage of the Sparta system was its social and political stability. The strict social hierarchy in Sparta, with its emphasis on discipline and obedience, helped to maintain order and stability within the city-state. Additionally, Sparta had a unique political system that was characterized by a strong central government and a lack of democracy, which some argue helped to prevent the kind of factionalism and internal strife that plagued other city-states in ancient Greece.
However, the Sparta system also had several significant drawbacks. One of the most notable was the lack of individual freedom and autonomy enjoyed by Sparta's citizens. The strict social hierarchy and emphasis on obedience and conformity meant that individuals had limited opportunities to make their own decisions or pursue their own interests. This lack of freedom was especially pronounced for the helots, a class of slaves that made up the majority of the population in Sparta. The helots were treated as property, and were not afforded any of the rights or freedoms enjoyed by Spartan citizens.
Another drawback of the Sparta system was its limited cultural and intellectual development. The strict focus on military training and discipline meant that there was little room for artistic or intellectual pursuits in Sparta. This lack of cultural and intellectual development meant that Sparta was not a center of innovation or progress in the ancient Greek world, and that its citizens were not exposed to the same range of ideas and cultural experiences as those living in other city-states.
In conclusion, the Sparta system had both advantages and drawbacks. While its strong military and stable social and political system provided some benefits, the lack of individual freedom and cultural and intellectual development had negative impacts on its citizens and on the broader ancient Greek world.
Sparta
This group can focus on providing the day-to-day needs of the society so that everyone else can focus on their job, their family, or pursuing their goals. Sparta was a Greek city-state whose sole purpose was military strength. This form of oligarchical government was elected by Spartan citizens who were over thirty years of age. They could also own property by themselves. That means anyone has the potential to join the ruling class, especially from a business perspective. Sparta became a military stronghold by emphasizing only on expanding their power and gaining control over other kingdoms, while the Athenians grew in the fields of infrastructure and culture. Although Sparta did not have a significant amount of participation in law by common people, it was able to create and sustain… The Pros And Cons Of Lycurgan Sparta downsides to every civilization and way of life.
Sparta and Athens were the most powerful states of ancient Greece; they were also each others biggest rivals. Unlike Sparta, in Athens, boys were not forced to join the army. However, women had limited rights and were not considered important. Unlike Sparta, men were not forced to join the army, they had the freedom to do anything that they desired. A benefit of holding a system where the armed forces would take control of the lives of work forces would be the warrant of nutrient and housing for the citizens of the state.
Spartan lawgivers wanted girls to receive a good education in order to prepare them to their womanhood duties. The people of Sparta preserved this physical superiority in many ways. Athens is the capital and the largest city of Greece. Athens used walls for their defense against other city-states. This is not the case. In Sparta, women had rights that other Greek women did not have. Two of the most well known and powerful city-states were Sparta and Athens.
These individuals from the Assembly were picked, by the fair evaluators, who sat in an alternate room and tuned in for the loudest cheer for every hopeful. They could work on innovating new technologies or ideas. This is not the case. They had much more rights and freedoms than other Greek women, but in terms of family life they were not so lucky. Women were living separately from spouse during their whole lives.
List of the 5 Cons of an Oligarchy 1. The kings, elders, and rulers of the Spartan government knew what was best for the citizens of Sparta, and, as a consequence, created strictly regimented rules that shaped Spartan lives for the better. What type of government did Sparta have? Why is Athens the best city-state? The value of adult females as persons was looked down upon as the statement mental instruction was non wasted upon the Spartan miss was said. In this case, there are invariably more reasons why Lycurgan Sparta was a less desirable place for the average citizen than Solonian Athens. The Evrotas not only provided Sparta with a source of water and protection, but also provided them with extremely fertile soil to grow many variants of crops such as wheat, barley, whole grains, etc. The oligarchy structure in Sparta enabled it to keep war as a top priority. Professionals and Cons of the Spartans A positive facet of the Spartan Code was the thought to develop their immature beginning at a immature age, by giving power to the province to command the young person.
So, as we have seen with these three countries each had a different set of politics that worked for them but not so much for each other. Differences — Similarities — Athens versus Sparta comparison chart Athens Sparta About The capital and largest city of Greece. Sparta was located along its left bank and had one central bridge running across it so as to stop invaders if necessary. At the age of 30 a Spartan was entitled to vote and would be allowed to stay at home. And both had their very own benefits and unbeneficial The Success And Potential Problems Of The Company Introduction With the rapid globalization of the market, innovation tends to be increasingly important in service industry and service management literature. Women were running as athletes during religious festivals that made in honor of female goddesses.
Professionals and Cons of the Spartans Essay Example
First, the army of Sparta was the strongest fighting force in Greece. This same method of unfairness was used as the poorer categories of the Spartan civilization had no rights as persons in political issues. Sparta was a warrior society in ancient Greece that reached the height of its power after defeating rival city-state Athens in the Peloponnesian War 431-404 B. Xenophon, a famous Athenian general, stated Are Prisons Effective? A single leader would struggle under a proper oligarchy to take a business or government toward risky ventures because risk would reduce the status quo for everyone in that society. Even though the Spartans did not focus on education that much, they still were able to create weapons that caused them to be greatly successful. There were broad governing rules to ensure that no part, or branch, turned out to be too intense. The Spartans were brought up to believe that they were supreme and that the universe could non learn them anything.
Many of the arguments against Sparta reason that government officials did not grant enough power to the people of the city-state, and therefore favor Athens. Home of many ancient philosophers, historians, and authors. It encourages a conservative approach. This not only ensured that all citizens were able-bodied and working to improve the city-state at all times, but improved the gene pool of the civilization by eliminating any possible genetic disorders with visible phenotypes within the society. During the time of 5th century in Sparta emerged a tiny powerhouse in the eastern Mediterranean, rivaled against Athens. Education in Sparta: did the pros exceed the cons? These people have the power to control everyone else within that specific society.
A citizen would have a say on how the state would run. Male Spartans were allowed one occupation: soldier. The two rulers were a piece of the administration for convention were the Council of Elders, or Gerousia, a gathering of twenty-eight Spartiate men and the two lords that who make charges, that the Assembly, or basic man, vote on. Between both, they had an Assembly, with members that were elected by the people. What made them work for one country and not in another? Here is a pros and cons list that looks at the other aspects of an oligarchy. It relies on either oppression or public obedience so that it can exist.
One of the ways that jurisprudence was maintained was by learning a lesson by the incorrect behaviors of another actions. They could all be taught the same concepts, and this would create more unity among the people which was very important, although the method by which they took action upon this was somewhat controversial. Why were Athens and Sparta rivals? Essay about Athens: The Superior Polis Compared to Sparta Athens was a much more superior polis compared to Sparta because the Athenians invented new ideas and creations that supported the people, such as democracy, the Athenians led the Delian League, and Sparta created the Peloponnesian League after the Athenians created their alliance, and the Athenians changed the ways of their government many times to suit the people, and the Spartans did not. The one thing that was very similar to them were their forms of government. The Spartans devoted all their time to the military, partaking in military training, hunting and war battles.
