A qualitative article critique is a critical evaluation of a qualitative research study. It involves examining the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. In order to effectively critique a qualitative article, it is important to have a solid understanding of qualitative research methods and the specific research tradition within which the study is situated.
When evaluating the research question of a qualitative article, it is important to consider whether the question is clear, relevant, and appropriate for a qualitative study. The question should be grounded in the existing literature and should address a gap in knowledge or understanding. It should also be feasible to answer using qualitative methods.
The study design of a qualitative research study should be well-planned and appropriate for the research question. This includes the choice of research setting, participants, and data collection methods. It is important to consider whether the design allows the researchers to explore the research question in depth and to generate rich, nuanced data.
Data collection is a critical aspect of qualitative research, as it determines the type and quality of data that is collected. It is important to consider the appropriateness of the data collection methods used in the study, as well as the rigor with which they were implemented. For example, were multiple data sources used, such as interviews, observations, and documents? Were the data collected in a systematic and transparent manner?
Data analysis is also a key component of a qualitative research study. It is important to consider the techniques used to analyze the data, as well as the rigor with which they were applied. Were the data analyzed in a systematic and transparent manner, using appropriate coding and categorization techniques? Were the findings supported by the data and were the conclusions drawn by the researchers supported by the data?
In conclusion, a qualitative article critique involves a critical evaluation of the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. It is important to consider the rigor and appropriateness of these aspects of the study in order to determine the validity and reliability of the findings. By conducting a thorough critique of a qualitative research study, researchers can gain a deeper understanding of the study and its implications for future research.
"The TrueBlue Study": Qualitative Article Critique
Completeness and appropriateness of the collected data to the research question The quality of research should be based on the completeness, comprehensiveness, and appropriateness of the collected data rather than the number of respondents or length of observations. The large finance company that withdrew from the research might have participated in the research if they could get anonymity and total secureness that the companies name would not be published. The researcher adequately applied the principles of qualitative research to come out with a valid and reliable study. Many patients experience a number of different negative outcomes as a result of cancer-related pain that are difficult to overcome, including low mood and possible depression as a result of this experience Naga et. The discussion section allows the researchers to provide additional information for the outcomes of their analysis. Patients were asked a number of questions, and the interviews were recorded and transcribed for detail Rustoen et. This was used by the researcher to explore the experiences of the participants during acupuncture treatment.
This includes an understanding of the different dimensions that will support and improve patient care and treatment with respect to cancer-related pain, such as physiological, behavioral, and sociocultural needs Naga et. The trueblue study: Is practice-led collaborative care effective in the management of depression for patients with heart disease or diabetes. Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods, 2, 1-10. Lisa Russell has the great advantage of her gender, nationality, use of language, size and age to naturally blend in as a member of the studied group, because ethnography relies heavily on observations of interactions and interviews with participants in naturally occurring situation. REFERENCES A de Guzman et al 2013. Looking at the efforts of the researchers, one might be quick to commend the effort at safeguarding the rights of the participants. The nature of the research topic, scope and design of the study, quality of data, and the volume of information elicited from each participant are some of the factors we consider to determine if the number of participants and depth of observations was appropriate in accomplishing the purpose of the qualitative research.
The purpose statement is clear and easy to locate. Do they reflect the findings? The report was well written although the tone of the paper suggests that English language is not the primary language of the researchers. In consequence, the proposed nurse-led collaborative care will initiate better treatment and management for co-morbid depression, therefore reducing complex and increasing chronic disease burden. Other than the abstract that hints that the researchers use a qualitative, the research section reaffirms the information. Therefore, it is important to identify specific factors that will be influential in enabling nurses to achieve effective treatment goals and objectives for this population group over time Naga et. The research instruments used in the study are appropriate since they enabled the researchers to empirically measure if their intended outcome — testing the improvement in the depression score — had been achieved by nurse-led corroborative care.
Age also contributed to the way students react to the ethnographer along with what he or she is and is not allowed to do Hammersley and Atkinson, 1983. The study findings describe the demographics of the study population, along with descriptions of their pain and its level of intensity Rustoen et. Although the sample size can be determined before the beginning of the project, especially in quantitative research, additional participants may be recruited during a qualitative study based on saturation and recurrent patterning techniques. In sampling, she availed of the expertise of a psychiatrist who determined the diagnosis based on DSM-IV criteria and validated the diagnosis of substance dependence. Conclusion This analysis has demonstrated how quantitative research can be of significant importance to the nursing practice, particularly in coming up with a relevant body of knowledge that could be intrinsically used to improve the practice as well as expand care to patients.
Qualitative Article Critique Example Nursing Essay
In a way we will always try to understand the unknown, even though it is obvious that every individual has its own unique behavior and perspectives. Ethical considerations Ethical considerations are fundamental in qualitative research and should, therefore, be discussed in detail. The study design is described as qualitative description to obtain factual information from participant interviews to identify cancer-related pain management needs from a nursing-based perspective Rustoen et. However, literature synthesis is not provided. Acceptance of offers to carry out research depends on the wishes of beneficiaries; they get to choose whom they perceive to be their best options. It was also compatible with the nature and type of data gathered.
The study's limitation of difficulty in comparing with previous studies makes the interpretation of the results a little unstable. Volume 31 Number 1. We have proactive customer support agents to ensure clients' issues are addressed and orders delivered in a timely manner. Pain experience among patients receiving cancer treatment: a review. Interviewing is a central method in phenomenological studies. QUALITATIVE RESEARCH ARTICLE CRITIQUE 2 Qualitative Research Article Critique In 2015, the Middle Eastern Respiratory Syndrome MERS caused a major outbreak with a fatality rate of 35.
Some practical guidelines for effective sample-size determination. Is the context thoroughly described? To maintain the integrity of the research and safeguard ethical responsibility to the participants, one must ensure that the respondents are not influenced or coerced to participate in the study. Student Name: Student ID: APA Style Citation of Journal Article 1 : Purpose of the Study 1 : The goal of this qualitative methodology study was to investigate the psychological well-being and cultural readjustment experiences of relocated Indigenous athletes. Conclusion After critically analyzing both articles of Russel 2005 and Kamenou 2008 , I have learned that qualitative research adopts different and various knowledge claims, research strategies, and methods of data collection and analysis. Within a year of its birth the trust was already under the hawk-eyed media for problems regarding long waiting lists in the hospitals. Ressearch Topic The topic is how to discipline students.
Qualitative Article Critique Example [wl1p7qe0g5lj]
The fact that students did change their behavior means also that Lisa became invisible to the researched group. The purpose of the study was also well explained to the subjects and a consent form was also dispatched to seek their willingness to participate. Several key words were used to perform the systematic review, such as cancer pain and pain management Naga et. Both the qualitative and quantitative data collected for this study and the manner of their collection was appropriate. I faded into the background. Although, the researchers stated that they sought to formulate a theoretical model which would explain the survivorship as it occurs in the test subjects. To answer the study's critical research.
It is also likely that researchers unintentionally adjust what they observe from the participants, and mold it to their own perspectives. Moreover, the researchers made an effort to present the research findings in a concise form. Methodology The methodology chosen for the specific study should be justified and well-explicated to enhance the credibility of the qualitative research. Personal networking is seen as one of the best ways to get granted access to an organization Carr and Worth 2001. The authors clearly point out the gaps in the existing literature. The researchers also offered the test subjects to choose a location and time for the interview to take place. In my opinion, she put a lot of dedication and time into cognizing the narratives and behaviors of the students and failed to do the same with the teachers.
Qualitative article critique, Sample of Research papers
London, UK: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Brooker, D. To make errors and mistakes will contribute to further understanding and deeper knowledge. . Afterward, the practice nurse PN assesses the patients for physiological, lifestyle, and psychological risks before initiating follow-up visits for the two groups to evaluate the outcomes of the two groups in terms of disease management. The abstract also describes a summary of the information gathered from the interviews and the necessity to increase pain management knowledge from a nursing-based perspective Rustoen et. . The article selected is an example of experimental quantitative design.