Should children who commit crimes be tried as adults. Should Children Who Commit Certain Crimes Be Tried as... 2022-10-27
Should children who commit crimes be tried as adults Rating:
There is a longstanding debate over whether or not children who commit crimes should be tried as adults. On one hand, it is argued that children are not fully developed mentally and therefore should not be held to the same standards as adults. On the other hand, it is argued that some children are capable of committing heinous crimes and should therefore be held accountable for their actions.
One argument in favor of trying children as adults is that it serves as a deterrent. By holding children accountable for their actions and imposing harsher penalties, it is believed that it will discourage them from committing crimes in the future. This is especially true for more serious crimes, such as murder or rape, which can have a lasting impact on the victim and their family.
Another argument in favor of trying children as adults is that it allows for a more tailored and appropriate punishment. In many cases, the punishment for crimes committed by children may be too lenient and fail to adequately address the harm caused by the crime. By trying children as adults, it allows the court to impose a punishment that is more closely aligned with the severity of the crime.
However, there are also several arguments against trying children as adults. One of the main arguments is that children are not fully developed mentally and therefore should not be held to the same standards as adults. This is especially true for young children, who may not fully understand the consequences of their actions. In addition, children are more likely to be influenced by their peers and may not have the same level of impulse control as adults.
Another argument against trying children as adults is that it can have a negative impact on their development and future prospects. Children who are tried as adults may be more likely to end up in the adult criminal justice system, which can have a lasting impact on their ability to find employment, housing, and other opportunities later in life. In addition, children who are tried as adults may be more likely to suffer from mental health issues and other long-term consequences.
In conclusion, whether or not children who commit crimes should be tried as adults is a complex issue with valid arguments on both sides. While it is important to hold children accountable for their actions, it is also important to consider the potential negative consequences of trying them as adults. Ultimately, the decision to try a child as an adult should be based on a careful consideration of all relevant factors, including the severity of the crime, the child's age and mental development, and the potential long-term consequences.
Teens Should Absolutely Be Tried as Adults When They Commit Adult Crimes
If they choose to act in an adult manner then they should be treated as such. Studies further confirm that stressful situations only heighten the risk that emotion rather than rational thought, will guide the choices children make. I do believe all teens know right from wrong,… Juveniles Do Deserve Life Sentences Prompt Of the five articles in the Juvenile Justice module, only one stands out as the most effective in defending the stance that children should be tried as adults. One girl was sentenced to 25 years in a mental institution, while the other was given 40 years. While young people must be held accountable for serious crimes, the juvenile justice system exists for precisely that purpose.
25+ Of The Worst Crimes Commited By Children Ever JourneyRanger
Instead they claim that the killings were highly planned and vigilantly carried out. Unless you are mentally disabled, but that's a different topic I agree 100%. Results of those policies demonstrate that they have failed as recidivism rates for juveniles increased when prosecuted in adult court versus juvenile court. It doesn't matter on how we treat juveniles, jueveniles are doing way too much. It prevents a child from having a fresh start even after they make necessary changes.
Should Children Who Commit Certain Crimes Be Tried as...
Most young offenders do not become adult criminals. Similarly, teaching kids about not handling something that is dangerous or getting them to understand the consequences of their actions especially if parents have guns and revolvers in their houses is the job of the parents. I believe that if a child commits a crime and he has to suffer dire consequences will remember if the consequence is as harsh as the crime. Actions of most adults are usually as a result of a well thought plan of action. The environment at the adult prisoners is an environment where the young offenders learn to become harder and worse criminals.
Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults For Violent Crimes?
Most of these children were between the ages of 13-15 when they were sentenced. Trying them as adults will only make matters worse due to their inability to interact with society once set free. Never under estimate the knowledge of kids and youths due to their first impression, the way they look, dress and act. Daniel was 14 years old when he attacked his mother with a hammer. Although she was taken to the hospital, Queen was pronounced to have lost her life on arrival. An adult on the other hand knows that he has a lot to risk by engaging himself in murder crimes, he is well aware that he will have to spend the rest of his life in jail.
Should children who commit serious crimes face the same...
If juveniles are capable of committing heinous crimes who knows what else they are capable of. Youths who commit crimes are criminals; they are walking our streets, living as our neighbors, and in many instances committing additional crimes. Whether or not the juvenile offender should be tried in an adult court or otherwise, lies within the laws made by the state and federal legislators. Many believe that putting an adolescent in prison with a life sentence is a cruel and unfair punishment. Hence, punishment for such a child would be more detrimental than seeking to give counsel. Young people are very fragile and when they are tried the same way adults, then, they get exposed to many risks. Anything less would be a double standard.
Mclnerney, J, 1994: page 2 The opposing view is that children in their opinion are unable to grasp the consequences of their actions. In the past couple of years, the law changed to place underage delinquents in rehabilitation centers or juvenile hall for no more than a year rather than prison. Kids know when they get in trouble they will be detained for a few months or perhaps just a night. Jacob's sentence could have been shortened if investigated by school officials, social workers, and both prosecution and defense authorities to understand the situation at home. The perpetrators were just 12 and ten years old when they took part in one of the most horrific crimes committed by children of all time in South Yorkshire back in 2009. Confirmation 2, No real effect on crime- There is no evidence that shows that treating children as adults will reduce crime.
Free Research Paper About Should Children Who Commit Crime Be Tried As Adults
However, harsher laws do not lower the crime rate, sending these children to prison does nothing to benefit society. Juvenile sentences, in contrast, shield our youth from the unique dangers of adult facilities and preserve the possibility — however slight it may seem — of rehabilitation. Alexander Crisostomo was ordered to stand trial as an adult for killing a 41-year-old man when he was just 15. There has been a rise in prosecutorial discretion laws. A big debate that has gone on for some time is whether or not children who commit violent crimes should be tried as adults. The thinking capacity of an adult and that of a child are very different and it goes for the level of maturity as well Reaves 5.
📚 Should Minors Who Commit Violent Crimes be Tried as Adults? Free Essay, Research Paper Example
This fact blows my mind because it clearly states that if children go to adult prisons they will get worse in there. It is believed that the juvenile courts are established keepingage factor in mind rather than focusing on the crime factor. Also officials should fully consider neurological evidence when dealing with juvenile defenders because the adolescent brain is still growing. Research Plan Methods of Research A thorough qualitative research will be carried to determine whether minors who have committed vicious crimes should be tried as adults. Another negative influence would be that these children will emerge stronger or even better criminals than they were before because they are bound to acquire some survival skills from older inmates Kellerman par. However, those close to the teen said something changed after Alyssa attempted to take her own life.